The relevance criterion of argument evaluation: pragmatic interpretation
In the paper the relevance criterion for argument evaluation within informal logic. Dialectical relevance should be interpreted as a dialectical rather than a logical concept, which is the result of dialogical interpretation of argumentation process.
Подобные документы
Study the generally acknowledged definition of hermeneutics. Dynamics of development of the philosophical concept. The justification of the indissoluble unity of language semiotic and hermeneutic studies in the context of the process of interpretation.
статья, добавлен 19.02.2016Phenomena such as memory, experience, observation, anticipation and hope are all essential for the way time is understood. Modern issues in temporal logic. The Master Argument of Diodorus Cronus. Logic and Special Relativity. Graphs for Time and Modality.
книга, добавлен 09.04.2013The difference between conceptual explanations about the nature of uncertainty and related phenomena, on the one hand, and various philosophical theories of uncertainty, on the other. A major analysis of overvaluation, contextualism and degree theory.
статья, добавлен 23.09.2020Features of the historical transformation of the philosophical methodology of cognition in the creative heritage of B. Spinoza. Analysis of the concept of substance, which plays a meaningful (backbone) and formal (methodological) role in his philosophy.
статья, добавлен 03.05.2023Formal axiomatic theory of Sigma as a result of logical formalization of philosophical epistemology. Acquaintance with the main features of the application of logic to philosophical theology. The essence of the concept of "formal-axiological equivalence".
статья, добавлен 15.09.2020M. Friedman and F. Kitcher proposed a model of the explanatory unity of knowledge, where the principle of unification is related to understanding, and the unity of a scientific theory was determined by how useful it is in creating a coherent argument.
статья, добавлен 28.07.2022Return to the integration of sociological, normative approaches to science. Rejection of the political component of Marxism. Scrupulous discussions between Lakatos and Feyerabend. A model of combining the history of science and its normative evaluation.
статья, добавлен 20.01.2022The scientific paper covers the matter of post-metaphysical thinking in law, the relevance of which is evidenced by the crisis offundamental jurisprudence as a consequence of the refusal to comprehend ultimate grounds inherent in modern thought.
статья, добавлен 27.06.2022Heraclitus - the founder of the dialectic. The analysis of the fragments-quotes book "On the nature". Five doctrines of the teachings of Heraclitus and their interpretation. Logos as the criterion of truth, the idea of universal variability and movement.
статья, добавлен 09.09.2012Analysis of the main approaches to the interpretation of volitional actions in analytical legal philosophy, in the context of legal responsibility and discussions about free will. The philosophical argumentation in Gilbert Ryle’s logical behaviorism.
статья, добавлен 23.09.2020Conceptualization of the phenomenon of "Absolute right" as a basic principle in the architectonics of ethical paradigms. Measuring the relevance of the "absolute" and "right" in the discourse of the panlogical philosophical and legal paradigm of G. Hegel.
статья, добавлен 04.10.2021The history of the development of constructivism and realism as philosophical positions included in the evolution of European philosophy. Changes in the views of V.A. Lektorsky – from dialectical materialism to the post-Marxist version of realism.
статья, добавлен 10.10.2023Dewey's metaphysics, a description of the generic traits of existence. Comparing the traits of nature with nature existing. Ontological status of real character. The continuity between logic and metaphysics. A non-ontological interpretation of logic.
статья, добавлен 10.09.2012Attempt to draw lessons from the metalogical philosophical texts. Interpretation of formulas as the basic truths or basic items of knowledge that are chosen as an axiom, an interpretation of a derivative truths - given appropriate transformation rules.
статья, добавлен 10.09.2012Theoretical understanding of the Husserlian model of the constitution of time modes, clarification of the possibilities of interpretation of its provisions in the reconstruction of the concept of anthropic time. Solving the problem of temporality.
статья, добавлен 11.12.2023Analyzes the works of a representative of Hegel`s German philosophy in the philosophical heritage of Ukrainian philosophers V.I. Shynkaruk, P. Kopnin and M. Bulatov. The dialectical method turns to research anthropological and ideological problems.
статья, добавлен 08.10.2020Ontological structure of quantum mechanics. The evolution of the henoontological equation (the identity of being one, of being) in the shape of the arrangement prepared by the orthodox interpretation of the theory. Focus on the Copenhagen interpretation.
статья, добавлен 07.11.2021The human cultural-creative activity: historical, dialectical, evolutionary, functional, ethnopsychological aspect. Ontological status of human cultural creation as a form of interaction between ethnic groups and nations in the era of globalization.
статья, добавлен 21.12.2021Strong argument for theological fatalism in the book "Freedom of the Will" written by J. Edwards. Discussion between Fatalists and Anti-Fatalists in the 20th century in the context ofthe most powerful argument for fatalism, introduced by Nelson Pike.
статья, добавлен 27.05.2022The epistemological difficulties in constructing integral concepts of legal understanding, suggest solutions for them, justify the option of integrative understanding of law based on a combination of dialectical and need-based methodological approaches.
статья, добавлен 07.07.2022The logic of history and the logic of its analysis in Marxism. Identity of logical and historical methods as anomaly in Marxism. Logical and historical methods as source of discussions in Marxism. The need to abandon the principle of historicism.
статья, добавлен 03.03.2021Suggesting an interpretation of Bergson's doctrine of Intuition which resolves the contradiction involved in the statement of his epistemology as found in his works. The intuition as a non-intellectual process which gives us knowledge through concepts.
статья, добавлен 10.09.2012Features of administrative-legal relations in the English interpretation. The role of English in the activities of a scientist-administrator. The need to pass a law on the mandatory translation of any international instrument that Ukraine concludes.
статья, добавлен 23.08.2018The Kantian formalism of John Rawls' Theory of Justice. The relevance of the concept of justice and the search for models of a well-organized society. The perniciousness of the agonal spirit of neoliberalism and the civil sense of justice and rationality.
статья, добавлен 25.04.2023The definition of the criterion of cultural and political rights of nations and nationalities in the era of globalization. Philosophical analysis and explanation of the concept of multiculturalism as a synthesis of the ideals of communism and liberalism.
статья, добавлен 24.05.2020